This is a story that could very well turn into a Hollywood movie showcasing the trials and tribulations of a common man. Ajay Dev is a 58-year-old engineer and Nepali immigrant. After enduring a harrowing 16-year prison sentence, he is finally free. Dev’s story is one for the books.
In 2009, Dev was convicted on 76 counts of sexual assault against his adopted daughter, Sapna Dev. In an unprecedented move, he was handed a sentence of 378 years.
His case stood as one of California’s most severe punishments for a non-homicide conviction. However, this month, a California judge overturned the conviction as she cited compelling new evidence. This evidence proves that the allegations were likely fabricated.
The allegations against Ajay Dev originated in 2004. It all started when his daughter Sapna accused him of sexually abusing her repeatedly over a period of years. Her claims became the foundation of a lengthy and emotional trial. In the end, Dev was convicted and then sentenced to almost 380 years.
However, over the years, there were some doubts about Sapna’s testimony and the credibility of the case.
Ajay Dev’s 378-year rape conviction overturned due to legal errors, mishandled evidence, and inconsistencies in the accuser’s testimony. The case highlights the flaws in California’s justice system and the challenges of wrongful convictions. #justicefordev, #wrongfulconviction,… pic.twitter.com/rJfb5h5gWn
— Vanguard News Group (@DavisVanguard) May 19, 2025
Recently, testimonies from four new witnesses were recorded that brought out the major shifts to the narrative. According to these individuals, Sapna admitted on multiple occasions that she had lied about the abuse. The reasons she gave were that she was angry at Dev and that she wanted to improve her chances of staying in the United States. None of these four people were called during the initial trial.
One particularly impactful testimony came from a witness. They revealed that Sapna had a difficult breakup. She lost her chance of staying in the US after that. So, she fabricated the charges so she could remain in the US.
Believe all women?
A judge overturned a California man’s 378-year sentence for sexual assault on Friday, May 23.
According to Superior Court of California, Yolo County court records reviewed by PEOPLE, Ajay Dev, 58, who had 76 convictions, was released on Friday, May 23, on his… pic.twitter.com/4kz2jnDaaF
— Satguy 141 (@satguy01) May 29, 2025
Such revelations were enough to cast significant doubt on the original trial’s outcome. It also prompted Judge Janene Beronio to reassess the integrity of the proceedings.
Judge Beronio is an experienced judge. She had spent nearly seven years reviewing the complex legal and evidentiary records of the case. She finally concluded that if these witnesses were presented in front of the jury and if the jury had heard the omitted witness statements, the verdict could have been completely different.
Judge Beronio acknowledged the grave doubts about Dev’s guilt and the likelihood that a miscarriage of justice had occurred.
The California Racial Justice Act is the most far-reaching act of its kind in the nation and puts California at the vanguard of legislative efforts to wring racial bias—conscious, unconscious, and systemic racism—out of our state’s criminal justice system (see below): pic.twitter.com/LsYRYU6913
— Jody David Armour (@NiggaTheory) June 14, 2024
Defence attorney Jennifer Mouzis further argued that the original prosecution relied heavily on racial and ethnic bias. Her claims resonated with California’s Racial Justice Act. It was passed in 2021 to address discrimination in the judicial process.
Ajay Dev was officially released on May 23, 2025. Yet, the legal chapter may not be fully closed. A court hearing is scheduled for June 13. During this hearing, it will be determined by the Yolo County District Attorney, Jeff Reisig’s next move. He could go ahead with a retrial of the case or can appeal the ruling. The DA’s office has not yet commented publicly on the judge’s decision.
Ajay Dev, 58, was released Friday after 16 years in prison for convictions of sexual assault on a minor and related charges. https://t.co/OHRKWmlhOF
— San Francisco Chronicle (@sfchronicle) May 28, 2025
Patricia Purcell, who has been a longtime advocate for Dev, expressed immense relief at the court’s ruling. She praised Judge Beronio for her diligence and courage in correcting what many believe was a deeply flawed conviction. “This is not just about one man’s freedom,” Purcell said. “It’s about holding the justice system accountable.”
Finally, Dev was able to reunite with his family after nearly two decades. His story stands as a stark reminder of the human cost of wrongful convictions. It is also a reminder of the critical importance of reexamining justice with both courage and compassion.
